Credibility Check: Expert Opinion
Evaluate the credibility of an expert's opinion or recommendation using the three-question framework.
Not all experts are equally credible, and even credible experts can be wrong outside their domain. This exercise helps you assess expertise systematically.
Guidelines:
- Name the specific expert and their claim or recommendation.
- Distinguish between domain expertise and this specific claim.
- Look for consensus vs. contrarian positions within the field.
- Synthesis should address: Would you act on this advice? What confidence level?
Time Limit
5:00